First we must start with a common background. As you may know, General McCrystal, the top US and NATO commander in Afghanistan, issued a report to the President and Secretary of Defense (on Aug. 30) which said, "Failure to gain the initiative and reverse insurgent momentum in the near-term (next 12 months) -- while Afghan security capacity matures -- risks an outcome where defeating the insurgency is no longer possible." McCrystal's assessment called for 40,000 more US troops to be sent to the theater in Afghanistan in order to prevent failure and defeat by the insurgents (for those who are interested, you can read the full report here).
Since Aug. 30, the President has been meeting with many national security leaders; military, civilian, academics, etc. to asses the situation before committing to sending more of our service men and women to the battlefield. I commend the President on his decision to take time and think through his options (something his predecessor did not do enough of--thinking) as there are many both tactically speaking and in terms of strategy and mission. While the President is 'thinking' Washington seems to be obsessed with whether or not the proper analogy for the conflict in Afghanistan is Iraq or Vietnam--both of which have obvious implications for US policy.
It is essential to understand that the battle we face in Afghanistan is vastly different from that of its neighbor Iraq or of our experiences in Vietnam. It differs in terms of history, geography, culture, and politics, all of which are crucial to understand completely when devising a strategy and war plans. There are also many actors involved in this complex theatre of operations--we have the Afghani Taliban, the Pakistani Taliban, and Al-Qaeda, all of whom have different goals, different origins, and different roles in the conflict.
To make this interactive, I am turning this over to you--what do you want to know about this conflict? What is confusing? Interesting? What can I write about that can teach you and make this complex situation a bit more understandable for those of you who don't follow insurgencies and counterterrorism like I do?? Bring on your questions, comments, thoughts, and over the next few weeks I will begin to write posts to address your questions (with a little Gerri flare).
Some thoughts that may be interesting to get into: What is an insurgency? How is Pakistan involved? How is the war in Iraq different from what we face in Afghanistan? What type of logistics go into sending troops abroad? What are the differences in the US Military Services and how do they all work together in the theatre of operation? Etc....I can play this game forever, so now its up to you.
Looking forward to our conversation...










